
This review is
from CNN's Mr. Showbiz entertainment
site. Very nice plot outline and insights by Paul Tatara. I appreciate
the sentiment of this review - particularly "Take any kid you can get your
hands on, and don't just drop them off at the theater." :-)
My thoughts exactly!
(If
you would like to view the article on CNN's page, click here)
Review: 'Iron Giant' a hugely entertaining
classic
August 9, 1999
Web posted at: 12:27 p.m. EDT (1627 GMT)
By Reviewer Paul Tatara
(CNN) -- For most filmgoers, the term
"animated feature" conjures up nothing
but songs and images from Walt Disney
movies, and that's only appropriate.
Disney has cranked out so many great
animated films over the years, their
storytelling approach and visual technique
have come to define the genre. Fanciful
narratives with a handful of catchy tunes
and well-defined characters (some of
whom are talking animals or dancing
objects) is more or less the way it's done.
There are certain pitfalls to any kind
redundancy, of course, but by now
you're practically volunteering for abuse if
you don't drop to your knees and weep
over everything Walt's boys churn out.
To even imply that there might be another
way of making these movies is viewed by
many as un-American.
That's because when people do take a
shot at making them another way, they
usually aren't talented enough to properly
pull it off. Or, more often than not, they
still keep the ball in Disney's court long
enough to remind you that what you're
watching is really just a camouflaged
rehash.
Well, Disney's stranglehold on America's
collective imagination may finally be
coming to an end. Warner Brothers' "The
Iron Giant" is not only the best animated
feature to be released this summer, it's
the single best film to hit our screens so
far this year.
No stopping the show
Director Brad Bird and screenwriter Tim
McCanlies have freely adapted the late
British poet-laureate Ted Hughes' classic
1968 story of a boy and his gigantic
robot, "The Iron Man," into a funny,
wonderfully touching fable about the
destructive nature of war and weaponry.
And -- get this -- there's not a single
musical interlude.
Bird departs from the accepted Disney
approach in a number of key ways. The
main characters -- aside from, of course,
the sweetly perplexed robot -- are very
much human, and the animation isn't
exactly heavy on glistening dewdrops.
It's no accident that "The Iron Giant"
movie poster is the most evocative one to
grace theater walls in years, not that
there's been much competition. Set in a
small American town in the 1950s, the
film's style is more reminiscent of the
graphic novels and science-fiction
pictures of the Eisenhower era than anything Disney's ever done, with a
touch of Max Fleischer's brilliant "Superman" cartoons thrown in for good
measure.
The movie's playful look and sharp adults-included tone are a hugely needed
breath of cinematic fresh air. It's an overused term, but Bird has a unique
vision, and he's delivered a classic. Not bad for a guy who's never directed
a
film before.
Falling to Earth
The story takes place in 1957, one of the coldest years of the Cold War,
when the Soviet-launched Sputnik satellite had Americans nervously
awaiting technological Armageddon. One night during a frightening
nor'easter, a huge comet streaks from the pouring sky and lands in the
ocean. The next night, a young boy named Hogarth (voiced by Eli
Marienthal) wanders away from home while his single mother (Jennifer
Aniston, doing a gracious, motherly job of it) is working overtime at the
local
diner.
What Hogarth finds in roaming the woods is the identity of that comet:
a
massive iron robot hoping to make a quick snack out of an electrical power
plant. The unsuspecting giant is soon on the verge of being fried by the
current, and Hogarth finds the plant's kill switch just in time to save
him from
a permanent meltdown. This initiates a charming "E.T."-like friendship
between the boy and the intimidating but apparently benign metal giant.
The mechanics of the story are certainly familiar enough. A boy makes a
secret, otherworldly friend, then has to hide him from the uncomprehending
adult world. But the way in which Bird and McCanlies open up the playing
field are unexpectedly wry.
Hogarth soon introduces the giant to a shade-wearing junkman-sculptor
(Harry Connick Jr., and the character looks just like him) who adds an
amusing element of hip bebop to the proceedings. He appreciates the giant's
ability to help him build larger, more sophisticated avant-garde sculptures.
But the fun is often not as pronounced as all that. For instance, Hogarth's
schoolteacher shows her students a hilarious "duck and cover" film called
"Atomic Holocaust" that's even more ridiculous than the ones children were
actually shown at the time. The lyrics of the reel's theme song are buried
by
classroom dialogue, but they're almost casually receptive to the idea that
the
kids who aren't listening will be fried to a crisp when the bomb hits.
There's also a nicely utilized catalogue of amusing 1950s rock tunes, the
cheesier the better. They never take center stage, but still evoke a time
when
pop Americana could be recognized as the creation of individual human
beings.
Mighty morphing
Individuality, as it is in most kids' films,
is an underlying theme, but the story
takes an interesting turn when a
government agent (the very funny
Christopher McDonald) shows up
trying to find out what's been eating all
the power lines and corn silos in the
area. Although the origins of the
virtually silent giant are never revealed,
it's eventually discovered that he's
some sort of superweapon.
The scenes when he's being hidden from the befuddled agent and a company
of Army tanks (the tight-jawed General is voiced by John Mahoney of
"Frasier") are clever, but the giant's unwilling conversion to a killing
machine
when he's attacked by fighter jets is surprisingly powerful.
The animators used computer techniques to give the giant his memorably
mechanized swivel, and his delightfully inelegant movements are bastardized
by his sudden display of firepower. Bird has said that the idea behind
the film
is "what if a gun had a soul and decided not to kill?" -- and that's certainly
a
timely thing for children to be hearing. The giant's inward battle against
his
pre-programmed goal is all the more poignant because we've grown to love
his tender demeanor.
The ending, which I won't give away, is unbelievably touching. A tearful
sacrifice is made, and we're then rescued from despair by a piece of
glorious, life-affirming magic. Here's to hoping that the giant will be
heard
from again, and that Brad Bird will be given free reign in bringing him
to life.
"The Iron Giant" is suitable for most children, but it has to be stressed
that adults will find a great deal to enjoy in its quick-witted asides.
Tears
will definitely fall, but the ending is one of pure redemption. Take any
kid you can get your hands on, and don't just drop them off at the
theater. Rated PG. 86 minutes.
"The Iron Giant" is produced and distributed by CNN Interactive sister
company Warner Bros., a Time Warner property.
CNN
Online





This site is still under construction.
Email me with any suggestions, input or whatnot.